Skip to main content

Succession planning is no longer simply a question of who takes over when a partner retires. In the first of a special Legal Sector Resilience Podcast series with Menzies LLP, Legal News Wales speaks to Paul James, Redkite Solicitors and Rachel Lai and Ross Wiggins at Menzies, about the decisions shaping the future of law firms, from investment and leadership development to acquisitions, culture and long-term sustainability.

For many law firms, succession planning remains a conversation for another day. One to have when a partner approaches retirement, when a potential buyer comes knocking or when the next generation is ready to take on equity.

But what happens when those conversations come too late? And could a different approach to succession unlock opportunities for growth, investment and stronger leadership?

Hosted by Legal News Wales founder Emma Waddingham, the episode brings together:

– Rachel Lai, Partner in Menzies LLP‘s Restructuring & Insolvency team (profile)

– Ross Wiggins, Partner & head of Menzies LLP‘s Deal Advisory team (profile)

– Paul James, Partner & head of commercial services at Redkite Solicitors (profile), whose law firm’s growth journey offers a compelling example of how succession challenges can become opportunities.

The discussion also reflects findings from the Welsh Legal Sector Transformation Report 2026, published by Legal News Wales in partnership with Osprey Approach, with expert input from Menzies LLP and other contributors.

The research found that 42% of responding firms had no succession plan currently in place, including those intending to develop one, while a third identified a lack of suitable internal candidates as a barrier.

Turning succession challenges into opportunities for growth

Redkite’s journey demonstrates how succession can be approached as a strategic opportunity rather than simply an exit process.

Founded through the merger of two West Wales practices in 2011, the firm began acquiring other businesses in 2016, initially targeting smaller practices whose owners were approaching retirement without an obvious succession solution.

Paul explained:

“At the outset, it was succession of the firms that we were looking to acquire as opposed to our succession ourselves.”

What began as a way of supporting other practices and their clients developed into a significant growth strategy. Redkite now operates from 19 offices, employing approximately 320 people, having completed a series of acquisitions.

Yet Paul acknowledged that many of the firms Redkite encountered had not addressed succession early enough.

“I think the common thread was the conversations weren’t happening.”

For Redkite, that experience also reinforced the importance of developing its own future leadership and ownership arrangements.

The firm became an alternative business structure (ABS), opened equity investment opportunities more widely and established an executive board with a majority of non-lawyer members.

“Our business is not run by the equity partners and the people who own it. Our business is run by an exec board, who a majority of which are not lawyers.”

Paul described this approach as one of the most important changes the firm had made.

Planning for the business you want to become

For Ross Wiggins – a Deal Advisory Partner at Menzies LLP – succession planning must begin with a clear understanding of the firm’s longer-term ambitions.

“What where does the partnership want to be in five years’ time? Is it growth? Is it doing carrying on doing what it’s doing?”

The answers, he explained, should inform decisions about leadership, recruitment, service lines, geographical expansion and investment.

He suggested firms should be looking at least three to five years ahead, recognising that finding, recruiting and developing future leaders can take considerable time.

Rachel Lai, a Partner in restructuring and insolvency at Menzies LLP, highlighted the risks of delaying those decisions.

She explained that firms can become particularly vulnerable when an individual central to the business becomes unavailable through ill health or an unexpected departure.

Without a plan, the consequences can extend beyond leadership uncertainty to reduced turnover, difficulties servicing clients and cash flow pressures. Rachel said:

“Having that plan well in advance could be the difference between having a well-managed process where everyone is relatively happy and you know a slightly confusing mess.”

The discussion highlights why succession should be considered alongside wider business resilience, rather than treated as a separate issue.

Ownership and / or leadership?

One of the episode’s strongest themes challenges the traditional assumption that law firm owners must also be responsible for managing the business.

Paul explained that Redkite deliberately separates investment in the firm from the leadership responsibilities undertaken by individuals.

“Ownership and leadership are not necessarily the same thing.”

The firm has invested in executive expertise across finance, people and culture, client experience, business development and marketing, enabling its lawyers to focus on their strengths while ensuring the business has the specialist leadership needed to grow.

Paul also questioned whether traditional equity partnership arrangements remain attractive to the next generation of lawyers, particularly given changing expectations around flexibility, risk and work-life balance.

“What you don’t want is you don’t want their appetite for equity to be a blocker for their ambition.”

The distinction raises important questions for firms seeking to develop future leaders who may have the ability and ambition to shape the business without necessarily wanting to take on ownership.

The growing challenge of partnership valuations

Financial expectations present another significant barrier to succession.

Ross suggested that the traditional partnership model, in which incoming partners fund the retirement of existing owners through goodwill payments or annuity arrangements, is becoming increasingly difficult to sustain.

“I think what we are seeing is that there is a widening gap on expectation.”

He explained that perceptions of law firm valuations have changed alongside the growing presence of private equity and alternative ownership structures in the legal market.

However, the value owners believe their business should command may not always reflect its commercial performance or the ability of future partners to fund an acquisition.

“The next generation; do they want to borrow that amount of money to buy in to fund the retiring partners?”

Rachel added that disagreements over valuations can become particularly difficult where partnership or shareholder agreements have not been reviewed for many years.

She advised firms to ensure agreements contain appropriate valuation mechanisms and remain relevant to current circumstances.

The discussion also explored funding alternatives, including debt finance, external investment and new equity arrangements, with Rachel emphasising the importance of understanding what different funding structures mean for control, ownership and the firm’s future.

The importance of independent challenge

Before making decisions about succession, investment or acquisition, firms need an accurate understanding of their current financial and operational position.

Rachel encouraged leaders to seek an independent perspective, describing the value of having a trusted adviser or ‘critical best friend’ who can challenge assumptions and help establish what the business is actually worth and capable of achieving.

“It’s definitely great to have your plan, but you also need to know where you are now so that you can work out how to get from your current position to where you want to be.”

She stressed the importance of reliable management information, including performance data broken down by location, department or service line.

This reflects another finding from the Welsh Legal Sector Transformation Report, which revealed that just 8% of respondents use business intelligence or dashboarding tools.

For firms considering succession or external investment, the ability to demonstrate financial performance and identify areas of opportunity or weakness could prove critical.

Culture and integration: The foundations of sustainable growth

While financial performance is essential, Paul suggests that cultural compatibility is equally important when considering mergers and acquisitions.

“One piece of advice that I would give, and it’s really difficult to articulate, but on our acquisition strategy, one of our key drivers is a cultural compatibility.”

He explained that growth by acquisition must involve more than bringing businesses under a shared name.

“What you don’t want to be is a firm of or 10 different firms who have the same name.”

For Redkite, the objective has been to build one integrated firm while retaining the local relationships and community presence that made the acquired practices successful.

Ross shared that Menzies takes a similarly structured approach to acquisitions, assessing cultural compatibility, financial viability and the integration arrangements needed to bring teams together successfully.

Both organisations emphasised the importance of investing time in people, communication and shared values following an acquisition.

A wider challenge for legal services in Wales

The consequences of poor succession planning extend beyond individual law firms.

Across Wales, the future of smaller and regional practices has implications for the availability of legal advice, particularly in communities where local knowledge and longstanding client relationships remain essential.

The Welsh Legal Sector Transformation Report found that only 24% of respondents believed individuals and small businesses in their area had adequate access to affordable legal advice.

Paul emphasised the importance of preserving those local connections, even as firms grow.

“There’s absolutely room for everybody, but every firm really needs to consider what their USP is.”

He also highlighted the value of understanding the communities in which firms operate, recognising that clients in different parts of Wales may have very different needs.

The discussion therefore raises a wider question for the profession: how can law firms build commercially sustainable businesses while protecting the diversity of legal services available across Wales?

Succession as an opportunity, not a problem

The episode concludes with practical advice for law firm leaders considering their next steps.

For Ross, the priority is to change the way succession is discussed.

“What needs to change now to make succession an opportunity rather than a problem?”

Rachel encouraged firms to create time away from day-to-day pressures to examine their future, supported by reliable management information and open conversations about where the business is heading.

Paul urged leaders to challenge traditional assumptions and consider alternative approaches.

“You don’t have to do what everybody else is doing.”

His final message was equally clear: “Don’t wait for the problem to arise and then find the solution.”

Together, the discussion suggests that successful succession planning is not simply about replacing those who leave. It is about understanding the business, developing the people who will shape its future and creating the financial and operational foundations to support sustainable growth.

For Welsh law firms, those conversations may be among the most important they have over the next five years.

Listen to the podcast

Stream the Legal Sector Resilience Podcast (season 2, episode 5) below or via any major podcasting / audio platform.

Explore the research

The discussion complements the findings of the Welsh Legal Sector Transformation Report 2026, published by Legal News Wales in partnership with Osprey Approach, with contributions from Menzies LLP and other experts in the business of law.

Explore the research findings and access the free report, here.

A special series of the Legal Sector Resilience Podcast, hosted by:

 

 

In partnership with business advisory services specialists:

 

Emma Waddingham Legal News Wales

Emma Waddingham

Editor, Legal News

Emma Waddingham is the Editor & Founder of Legal News and the current President of Cardiff & District Law Society.

Emma is a seasoned legal editor and journalist and experienced marketing & events consultant, working almost exclusively with the UK legal sector.